my girl controversy

If Dhont had spoken to any medical professionals, he would know this!

I don’t know if Dhont had any transgender consultants on set while filming, because if he did, they would have warned him of the danger lying ahead.

However, in the video, she used a gesture using her hands, which is offensive, pertaining to a person who has a large physique.

This is mainly the stylists fault. On May 17, fans got furious after OH MY GIRL allegedly fat-shamed their senior idol, Super Junior's Shindong, and at the same time, for showing racist gestures. In addition to this, SBS KPOP's YouTube Channel also released their statement, saying, "But we've got to know this video can be hurtful towards some people, especially to international fans and to 'Miracles' (fandom name of OH MY GIRL). This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible.

(After this article was submitted, Girl received a Golden Globes nomination.). The Transgender Drama ‘Girl’ is Earning Awards Season Buzz – Here’s Why It’s Infuriating Trans Critics. In a year in which Hollywood is finally beginning to take the transgender community seriously when we speak up, it’s time that the Academy takes what we have to say to heart.

In the same episode, Hyojung allegedly fat-shamed Super Junior's Shindong, which is not only the host of the show but also their senior idol.

How is he supposed to have that conversation when so many trans critics won’t even have a chance to see the film before awards consideration?

Hopefully, we don’t have to deal with this again. Although very few trans critics have had a chance to see the film (more on that in a moment), all of them have noted the same thing: the film features many, too many, shots of Lara’s genitals.

The basic controversy around Girl is summed up quite well by … Lara is a ballerina and there should be a stronger focus on how that drives her rather than this need to harm her body because blockers aren’t helping as she starts hormones.

In the video, the group was playing a game where they have to guess words. YooA and Mimi were seen with a Bindi and Matha Patti. For starters, the film was from a cisgender filmmaker who chose to cast another cisgender male actor in the role of a transgender female. Would love your thoughts, please comment. While showing tucking onscreen, a reality for many trans women, can be important to represent, Dhont turns it into a bloody horror show. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

The controversy started during the broadcast of the SBS KPOP's YouTube show, "Shindong Gayo," wherein the Super Junior member is the MC.

The key one being that by casting cisgender actors — let alone focusing so much on the genitalia — he’s reinforcing the negative stereotype that transgender women are men.

Did he ever stop and think about the fact that he’s reinforcing awful stereotypes about the trans community? © Copyright 2017 KpopStarz.com. In a perfect world, my being a transgender woman would not be the thing that defines me. The male idol, nevertheless, started laughing, as well as the rest of the members. Even though film critics like me are able to get into For Your Consideration screenings for many films, these screenings are largely in cities like New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and London.

This time around, fans have taken up an issue with the girl group's styling during their KCON:TACT 2020 SUMMER performance. As the film began its festival run, critics wrote positive reviews.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings. Absent the controversy, Cuties would have been a blink-and-you-miss it newbie debuting in the middle of the week to minimal attention. I say this even when at least one of the critics groups I’m in goes by the same rules as the Oscars for Best Foreign Language Film. apologizing as well for fans who were disappointed due to idol's act.

Don’t cancel, educate!

Being transgender should not be something that comes off as a prop.

No transition is the same but there are a lot of body changes that happen very slowly. Shortly after the film premiered, Netflix acquired the film, which is directed by Belgian filmmaker Lukas Dhont.

This time around, fans have taken up an issue with the girl group's styling during their KCON:TACT 2020 SUMMER performance.

I’m based in Chicago and going into early December, it seems highly doubtful that I’ll get an awards screener for, Meanwhile, the Los Angeles Online Film Critics Society nominated. Much like the cisgender characters who continually silence Lara and tell her how to feel, the director shows no interest in understanding her internal struggles. And I have a lot to say about Girl, which is a dangerous movie. Dhont’s obsession with genitalia reveals, whether intentional or not, a transphobic streak in the film. This will be after the Foreign Language Film Award Committee narrows the 87 Oscar submissions to six films ,with another three films voted by the Academy’s Foreign Language Film Award Executive Committee.

On May 17, fans got furious after OH MY GIRL allegedly fat-shamed their senior idol, Super Junior's Shindong, and at the same time, for showing racist gestures. YooA and Mimi were seen with a Bindi and Matha Patti.

How could this film even get nominated when trans voices have been speaking out since the premiere in May? Some would tackle the cisgender casting while others completely ignored it.

Top 12 Best Romance Korean Web Dramas To Have On Your Watchlist, OH MY GIRL 2020 ONLINE CONCERT [The Lost Memory]: Live Stream And Ticket Details, Some Fans Are Criticizing & Accusing NCT U Of Disrespecting Indian Culture, Here's How Some Reveluvs Are Defending Irene From Attitude Controversy, Red Velvet Irene Suspected For Alleged “Bad Attitude” Problem?

Girl is not the only foreign film that Netflix is campaigning for awards (the streaming giant is also heavily pushing Roma), but Girl is not included in their mailings to critics. In a year in which Hollywood is finally beginning to take the transgender community seriously when we speak up, it’s time that the Academy takes what we have to say to heart.

It’s trans trauma porn and, as a cisgender person, I’m warning trans people not to watch it and cis people not to fall for it.”. Get to know us, listen to us.”. It was the first time that I can recall a film with a trans woman playing a trans woman getting awards love left and right. Again, this is still taking place before Netflix releases Girl for all to see and before so many voices can chime in on why this film is a big, big problem. And I have a lot to say about Girl, which is a dangerous movie.

Rapper Swings Looking More & More Like Actor Park SeoJun.

Because Polster isn’t trans, he probably wasn’t thinking along the lines of how dangerous the film is.

However, this is not the only thing that didn't sit well with fans. YooA's jewel on her forehead has been compared to the red dot Hindu women have on their foreheads as a sign showing that they are married. All Rights Reserved.

Because of her age, Lara is on puberty blockers to prevent testosterone from damaging her body.

Indian culture is very sacred. But this world isn’t perfect and because I’m transgender, people turn to film critics such as me to hear what I have to say about movies like this.

However, as they were having fun, netizens noticed the problematic behaviors that OH MY GIRL portrayed in the episode. We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website. Any cisgender person claiming to be a trans ally would definitely not take the role of a trans actor. And, is what’s wrong with most projects that claim to represent the experiences of trans people with no substantive participation of trans voices.

What could have been a thoughtful exploration of a difficult part of a trans girl’s daily life instead uses her body as a site of trauma, inviting the audience to react with disgust.

By screening the film in select cities and not sending out awards screeners, this speaks to the lack of a level playing field.

If this film is nominated at the Oscars, it will be a slap in the face to the transgender community.

This isn’t the only problem. A transgender filmmaker wouldn’t obsess about genitalia in a film in which a trans person is the lead.

Privacy Policy / Cookie Policy. TWICE Mina Goes Viral With Korean Netizens... Can You Guess Why.

Why Oh Why Lyrics, The 40-year-old Virgin Filmyzilla, Australian Media, Yannick Ngakoue Dolphins, Maroon 5 - Memories, Buddha Nature Zen, Bfe Florida, Irene Red Velvet House, Peter Schlesinger Indagare, No Tears Lyrics, Accident Man Filmyzilla, Jab Tak Lyrics In English, The Magicians Season 1 Episode 13 Recap, Alex Marquez Salary, Fontainebleau Bouldering, Pokémon Isle Of Armor Pokedex, Andrew Parks Writer, Fabio Quartararo Taille, Meridian, Ms Fire Department, Pehli Nazar Mein Movie 1996, Daisy Lowe Mum, Richie Shelton Death, Like We Discussed Beforezubaan Meaning, Ricky Baker Boyz N The Hood, Greg Daniels, Does Florence Pugh Speak Spanish, Upload Season 2 Release Date Uk, Someone Like You Chords No Capo, Blackbird Song - Lee Dewyze Tab, La La Land Audition (the Fools Who Dream), Mike Alstott Net Worth, Jessie Potter Chris Potter, When Will Upload Season 2 Come Out, If Beale Street Could Talk Book Summary, Match Worn Rugby League Shirts, Where Is The Friend's Home English Subtitles, Don't Get Me Started Topics, Australian Media, Is There A Fire In Phoenix Today, Hard Rock Quotes, John Oliver Dunthorne Ii, Lee Kernaghan - Backroad Nation, Belarus Ruble To Usd, Circhester Bay Map, Naagin 3 All Actor Name, Mr Bleaney, The Traffickers (2012 Full Movie), Rocco And His Brothers Summary, Whats Poppin (remix Genius), Leverage Reboot, Ethan Meaning Bible, The Lego Movie 2 Videogame, Robert Wisdom The Wire, Live Streaming News Las Vegas, Say So Tiktok Dance, Quantitative Wildfire Risk Assessment, Wendi Mclendon-covey Goldbergs,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *